Skip to main content

Miracles & "Scientism"

      One of the toxic and false ideas of our age might be called scientism, the idea that science is the only path to truth.

      One online definition of “science” is, “the systematic study of the structure and behavior of the physical and natural world through observation, experimentation, and the testing of theories against the evidence obtained.” The earlier, classic definition of “science” was “knowledge of any kind,” meaning, of course, human knowledge.

      Is human knowledge the only path to truth? To knowing “what is”? (The best definition of “truth.”) Is, “systematic study of the structure and behavior of the physical and natural world,” the only path to truth? Even if we don’t understand everything about a cell, an atom, and how the universe works today, might we someday expect human science to figure it all out?

      No.

      Why does the world exist? Why do I exist? What am I here for? Am I only tissue? Then why and how do I have consciousness, even self-consciousness?

      And no matter how far back we go, whether we believe “evolution,” the “big bang” or some other theory, we still ask: but what was there before? What caused the first atom, the first particle, my consciousness?

      It is obvious and self-evident that there must be a Creator, This is self-evident, even to human reason.

      It’s also self-evident to human reason that we are finite and limited. There’s far more than we can ever understand and know.

      Miracles also evidence this. This -- both the Creator and our limitation on knowledge.

      Miracles are when the One who designed and created the “structure and behavior of the physical and natural world” chooses to dispense with them. They are divine interruptions. The greater force of God supplementing the usual behavior of nature.

      The man with stage four cancer is suddenly cancer-free (Bakersfield). The woman born blind who has no cornea, yet one day starts seeing clearly (still with no cornea; San Diego). The man who was once a Thalidomide baby, born with his hand near his shoulder, watches it grow out over 30 minutes as a group of Believers pray steadily for his healing until the arm is normal (Seattle). These are real and true events. Beyond nature, beyond science. Miracles.

      The Christianity the Apostles taught has always been very comfortable with miracles. Christianity is founded on miracles. God miraculously entered the world by taking on the form of humanity – flesh and blood, human body and human soul. Jesus, the Messiah, the Christ.

      When Jesus was executed and died, He miraculously rose from the dead. He was not resuscitated. No “near death” experience. He did die. His miraculous, resurrected body was in a whole new dimension. It was outside the “structure and behavior of the physical and natural world.” He could eat food, but not have to. He could appear and disappear. He could walk through locked doors.

      Some time before He died, He was transfigured into an earthly appearance of God’s (His) glory. The three witnesses (Peter, James and his brother, John) saw the heavenly and eternal aspect of Jesus’ future resurrected and ascended glory – the fullness of Divine glory which His human body, blood, and soul shared after His resurrection and ascension to God the Father.

      When Jesus said, “This is My Body. This is My Blood,” and commanded his Apostles and their successors, “Do this in memory of Me,” another miracle occurred. His Word was effective. The unleavened bread and the wine became Jesus’ Body and Blood, His human soul and His Divinity. By the offering of Himself the night before He died, Jesus’ execution the next day was an offered sacrifice constituting and effecting the New Covenant in His life’s Blood.

      Want to see a miracle? It occurs at every Mass when the priest obeys the Lord’s command, “Do this in memory of Me.”

Dibby Allan Green


Originally published in the print edition of the Mojave Desert News of October 18, 2023. 
Our Lady of Lourdes Catholic Church is located in California City, CA. Visit our website at ollcalcity.org
Dibby Allan Green has a BA in Religious Studies (Westmont College, 1978) and MA in Theology (Augustine Institute, 2019), is a lay Catholic hermit, and a parishioner of Our Lady of Lourdes Parish